Black and white are the two colours that look easiest and are hardest to paint. Pure black has no highlights to show its shape, so it reads as a flat hole; pure white has no shadows, so it looks like bare primer. The trick with both is that you never actually use much pure black or pure white. Black is really a ramp of dark greys; white is really a ramp of light greys.
This guide gives the ramps for each, with the closest real paints in every brand on the site, and the mistakes that make black look grey and white look dirty.
Basecoat in black, then highlight with dark greys, keeping each step smaller than the last. Most of the model should stay black; the highlights only describe the edges and the tops of the shapes. The more steps you use and the smaller the final one is, the blacker the area still looks.
| Brand | Black base | Highlight 1 | Highlight 2 | Final highlight |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Citadel | Abaddon BlackColour: Base · ΔE 2, close | Dataslate GreyTone Pro · ΔE 6, fair | Blackstone VoidTone Pro · ΔE 1, close | Enrapturess DuskTone Pro · ΔE 7, fair |
| Vallejo | BlackModel Color · ΔE 4, close | Olive GreenModel Air · ΔE 3, close | Dark GrayModel Air · ΔE 2, close | Light GreyModel Color · ΔE 3, close |
| Army Painter | Matt BlackWarpaints Air · ΔE 2, close | Strap GreyWarpaints Historical · ΔE 1, close | Deep GreyWarpaints Fanatic · ΔE 5, close | Uniform GreyWarpaints Fanatic · ΔE 4, close |
| Pro Acryl | Coal BlackStandard / Signature / AMP · ΔE 1, close | Blue BlackStandard / Signature / AMP · ΔE 9, fair | Neutral GreyStandard / Signature / AMP · ΔE 2, close | Grey GreenStandard / Signature / AMP · ΔE 12, fair |
| AK Interactive | BlackAK Quick Gen · ΔE 4, close | Soft BlackAK Quick Gen · ΔE 2, close | RAF Extra Dark Sea Grey BS381C/6403rd Gen Air Series · ΔE 3, close | Dark Gull Grey FS 362313rd Gen Air Series · ΔE 3, close |
| Two Thin Coats | No close match | Doom Death BlackTriads: shadows · ΔE 5, close | Faust BlueTriads: shadows · ΔE 3, close | Gravestone BlueTriads: highlights · ΔE 6, close |
| Reaper | Pure BlackMaster Series Paints · ΔE 3, close | Midnight BlueMaster Series Paints · ΔE 6, close | Stormy GreyMaster Series Paints · ΔE 7, fair | Rainy GreyMaster Series Paints · ΔE 5, close |
| Formula P3 | Thamar BlackFormula P3 · ΔE 3, close | Asheth GreyFormula P3 · ΔE 5, close | Greatcoat GreyFormula P3 · ΔE 4, close | Ironhull GreyFormula P3 · ΔE 5, close |
| Golden | Carbon BlackHeavy Body Acrylics · ΔE 3, close | Paynes GrayHeavy Body Acrylics · ΔE 6, close | Graphite GrayHeavy Body Acrylics · ΔE 7, fair | N5 Neutral GrayHeavy Body Acrylics · ΔE 8, fair |
| Nocturna Models | Outlining BlackN-Paint Basic · ΔE 5, close | Slate GreyN-Paint Basic · ΔE 11, fair | Darkness GreyN-Paint Basic · ΔE 4, close | Pilgrim GreyN-Paint Basic · ΔE 9, fair |
| Bear Cavalry | No close match | Ultimate Cup of CoffeeBear Cavalry Paints · ΔE 15, loose | Fade to BlackBear Cavalry Paints · ΔE 8, fair | RavenskillBear Cavalry Paints · ΔE 9, fair |
| Scale75 | BlackScalecolor · ΔE 6, close | Green GreyScalecolor Artist · ΔE 2, close | Rlyeh GreyFantasy & Games · ΔE 6, close | GraphiteScalecolor · ΔE 8, fair |
| Tamiya | Flat BlackXF Flat Acrylic · ΔE 6, close | NATO BlackXF Flat Acrylic · ΔE 7, fair | Gray Violet (Luftwaffe)AS Spray (aircraft) · ΔE 3, close | IJN Gray (Maizuru Arsenal)XF Flat Acrylic · ΔE 5, close |
| Mr. Hobby | BlackMr. Color · ΔE 7, fair | RLM 66 Black GrayAqueous Hobby Color · ΔE 4, close | JMSDF 2705 Dark Gray N4Mr. Color · ΔE 3, close | IJN Hull Color/KureMr. Color · ΔE 2, close |
| AMMO by Mig | BlackOilbrusher · ΔE 1, close | Black BrownDio Drybrush · ΔE 5, close | Slate GreyAcrylic Colors for Figures · ΔE 5, close | Grauviolett RLM 75ATOM · ΔE 4, close |
| Green Stuff World | Black StallionAcrylic Colors · ΔE 6, close | Blackroot GreyAcrylic Colors · ΔE 3, close | Terror Blue-GreyOpaque Colors · ΔE 6, fair | Grey TealAcrylic Colors · ΔE 15, loose |
Target colours along the top; under each, the closest paint in that brand by swatch colour (ΔE under 6 is close, under 12 fair). Swatch colours are estimates, so check against the real pots.
A neutral grey ramp looks like black plastic or armour. Adding a little blue to the highlights (a blue-grey) makes black look cooler and shinier, which suits armour, Space Marines and leather boots. A warm grey, or a touch of brown, suits black cloth, fur and horses. And for black that should feel like a colour (deep blue-black hair, a black dragon with a purple sheen) highlight with a very dark version of that colour instead of grey.
You can build any of these on the colour wheel: tap a black or a dark blue-grey in Ramps mode with Edge highlights and it builds the steps from the paints you choose.
Paint white from a light grey upwards, so that the shadows are grey and the pure white is only on the top. Painting straight white over black primer takes many coats and still looks chalky; a light grey basecoat over grey or white primer covers easily and gives you the shadows for free.
| Brand | Shadow grey | Light grey | Off-white | White |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Citadel | Administratum GreyColour: Layer · ΔE 3, close | Longbeard GreyColour: Dry · ΔE 7, fair | Corax WhiteColour: Base · ΔE 5, close | White ScarColour: Layer · ΔE 2, close |
| Vallejo | Light GrayModel Air · ΔE 3, close | GreyModel Air · ΔE 2, close | White GreyModel Color · ΔE 3, close | WhiteModel Air · ΔE 2, close |
| Army Painter | Cadre GreyWarpaints Air · ΔE 2, close | Yeti WhiteWarpaints Air · ΔE 3, close | Brainmatter BeigeWarpaints Fanatic · ΔE 3, close | Matt WhiteWarpaints Air · ΔE 3, close |
| Pro Acryl | Bright Brown GreyStandard / Signature / AMP · ΔE 11, fair | Bright Neutral GreyStandard / Signature / AMP · ΔE 5, close | Dark IvoryStandard / Signature / AMP · ΔE 7, fair | Heavy Warm WhiteStandard / Signature / AMP · ΔE 12, loose |
| AK Interactive | Dark Ghost Grey FS 363203rd Gen Air Series · ΔE 4, close | Spectrum Blue3rd Gen Standard · ΔE 5, close | AE-9/AII Light Grey3rd Gen Air Series · ΔE 3, close | White Grey3rd Gen Standard · ΔE 3, close |
| Two Thin Coats | Carcharodon GreyTriads: midtones · ΔE 4, close | Ivory TuskTriads: midtones · ΔE 9, fair | Trooper WhiteTriads: highlights · ΔE 5, close | White StarTriads: highlights · ΔE 2, close |
| Reaper | Icy GreyMaster Series Paints · ΔE 4, close | Misty GreyMaster Series Paints · ΔE 2, close | Leather WhiteMaster Series Paints · ΔE 6, close | Pure WhiteMaster Series Paints · ΔE 3, close |
| Formula P3 | Ironhull GreyFormula P3 · ΔE 3, close | Trollblood HighlightFormula P3 · ΔE 15, loose | Underbelly BlueFormula P3 · ΔE 9, fair | Morrow WhiteFormula P3 · ΔE 5, close |
| Golden | N6 Neutral GrayHeavy Body Acrylics · ΔE 5, close | N7 Neutral GrayHeavy Body Acrylics · ΔE 3, close | N8 Neutral GrayHeavy Body Acrylics · ΔE 7, fair | Zinc WhiteHeavy Body Acrylics · ΔE 2, close |
| Nocturna Models | Pilgrim GreyN-Paint Basic · ΔE 7, fair | Granite StoneN-Paint Basic · ΔE 6, fair | Northern FleshN-Paint Basic · ΔE 10, fair | Sketching WhiteN-Paint Basic · ΔE 4, close |
| Bear Cavalry | Grey GooseBear Cavalry Paints · ΔE 4, close | Glass Moon LightBear Cavalry Paints · ΔE 8, fair | No close match | White RoomBear Cavalry Paints · ΔE 3, close |
| Scale75 | GraphiteScalecolor · ΔE 5, close | Miskatonic GreyFantasy & Games · ΔE 4, close | NacarScalecolor · ΔE 6, fair | Art WhiteScalecolor Artist · ΔE 1, close |
| Tamiya | Neutral Gray (USAF)AS Spray (aircraft) · ΔE 5, close | Royal Light GrayXF Flat Acrylic · ΔE 2, close | Insignia White (US Navy)AS Spray (aircraft) · ΔE 4, close | Flat WhiteXF Flat Acrylic · ΔE 5, close |
| Mr. Hobby | IJN Hull Color/KureMr. Color · ΔE 4, close | Light Gull GrayMr. Color · ΔE 2, close | RLM 76 Light BlueAqueous Hobby Color · ΔE 12, fair | Character WhiteMr. Color · ΔE 1, close |
| AMMO by Mig | GreyATOM · ΔE 1, close | Light GreyDio Drybrush · ΔE 4, close | Cold GrayATOM · ΔE 2, close | WhiteDio Drybrush · ΔE 2, close |
| Green Stuff World | Moonstone GreyAcrylic Colors · ΔE 7, fair | Wolven GreyAcrylic Colors · ΔE 6, close | Moon Mist GreyAcrylic Colors · ΔE 5, close | Nuclear WhiteAcrylic Colors · ΔE 5, close |
Target colours along the top; under each, the closest paint in that brand by swatch colour (ΔE under 6 is close, under 12 fair). Swatch colours are estimates, so check against the real pots.
White cloth, bone, ivory and parchment look better warm. Use a warm grey-brown for the shadows and creamy off-whites for the highlights, keeping pure white only for the very last points, or leave it out altogether.
| Brand | Warm shadow | Mid | Cream | Warm white |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Citadel | GnarlwoodTone Pro · ΔE 4, close | Necrolith BoneTone Pro · ΔE 5, close | WraithboneColour: Base · ΔE 5, close | Wrack WhiteColour: Dry · ΔE 4, close |
| Vallejo | Old WoodModel Color · ΔE 2, close | Desert TanModel Color · ΔE 1, close | Bone WhiteGame Color · ΔE 4, close | Off-WhiteModel Color · ΔE 2, close |
| Army Painter | Ammo Pouch BrownWarpaints Historical · ΔE 7, fair | Tomb King TanWarpaints Fanatic · ΔE 2, close | Ancient StoneWarpaints Fanatic · ΔE 3, close | Pale SandWarpaints Fanatic · ΔE 4, close |
| Pro Acryl | Brown GreyStandard / Signature / AMP · ΔE 6, fair | Beige GreyStandard / Signature / AMP · ΔE 10, fair | Olive FleshStandard / Signature / AMP · ΔE 3, close | Bright IvoryStandard / Signature / AMP · ΔE 5, close |
| AK Interactive | Reddish Grey3rd Gen Standard · ΔE 1, close | Warm Grey3rd Gen Standard · ΔE 4, close | Deck Tan3rd Gen Intense · ΔE 6, fair | Light Flesh3rd Gen Standard · ΔE 3, close |
| Two Thin Coats | Dust BowlTriads: shadows · ΔE 3, close | Skeleton LegionTriads: midtones · ΔE 7, fair | Ivory TuskTriads: midtones · ΔE 10, fair | Trooper WhiteTriads: highlights · ΔE 2, close |
| Reaper | Stone GreyMaster Series Paints · ΔE 9, fair | Khaki ShadowMaster Series Paints · ΔE 3, close | Bare BoneMaster Series Paints · ΔE 3, close | Pure WhiteMaster Series Paints · ΔE 8, fair |
| Formula P3 | Thornwood GreenFormula P3 · ΔE 10, fair | Cryx Bane HighlightFormula P3 · ΔE 10, fair | Trollblood HighlightFormula P3 · ΔE 9, fair | Ryn FleshFormula P3 · ΔE 9, fair |
| Golden | N4 Neutral GrayHeavy Body Acrylics · ΔE 14, loose | N6 Neutral GrayHeavy Body Acrylics · ΔE 17, loose | Titan Green PaleHeavy Body Acrylics · ΔE 9, fair | Zinc WhiteHeavy Body Acrylics · ΔE 7, fair |
| Nocturna Models | Evil FleshN-Paint Basic · ΔE 4, close | Yellow SandN-Paint Basic · ΔE 14, loose | Sand GreyN-Paint Basic · ΔE 3, close | Northern FleshN-Paint Basic · ΔE 4, close |
| Bear Cavalry | March of the Fire AntsBear Cavalry Paints · ΔE 6, fair | Bison-BeastBear Cavalry Paints · ΔE 12, fair | Glass Moon LightBear Cavalry Paints · ΔE 20, loose | White RoomBear Cavalry Paints · ΔE 9, fair |
| Scale75 | WalnutScalecolor · ΔE 10, fair | Thar BrownScalecolor · ΔE 5, close | Mojave WhiteScalecolor · ΔE 3, close | White SandsScalecolor · ΔE 4, close |
| Tamiya | Dark EarthAS Spray (aircraft) · ΔE 10, fair | Wooden Deck TanXF Flat Acrylic · ΔE 6, fair | Deck TanXF Flat Acrylic · ΔE 8, fair | J.A. GrayXF Flat Acrylic · ΔE 6, close |
| Mr. Hobby | Brown FS30219Mr. Color · ΔE 4, close | RLM 02 GrayMr. Color · ΔE 8, fair | Light Gray FS36495Aqueous Hobby Color · ΔE 15, loose | Character WhiteMr. Color · ΔE 5, close |
| AMMO by Mig | Pale EarthAcrylic Colors for Figures · ΔE 6, fair | Splinter GreyAcrylic Colors for Figures · ΔE 5, close | Old BoneIONIC Smart Colors · ΔE 3, close | Light FleshOilbrusher · ΔE 3, close |
| Green Stuff World | Granite GreyOpaque Colors · ΔE 7, fair | Dead FlushOpaque Colors · ΔE 15, loose | Whitecap BeigeAcrylic Colors · ΔE 5, close | Ivory TuskAcrylic Colors · ΔE 11, fair |
Target colours along the top; under each, the closest paint in that brand by swatch colour (ΔE under 6 is close, under 12 fair). Swatch colours are estimates, so check against the real pots.
A black wash such as Nuln Oil over a grey basecoat is a quick way to a good tabletop black: drybrush or edge highlight back up afterwards. For white, a thinned grey contrast paint such as Basilicanum Grey over white primer, or a white contrast paint like Apothecary White, gives soft grey shadows in one coat. A sepia or brown wash over cream gives an old, weathered white.
Basecoat black, then highlight with a very dark grey, a mid-dark grey and a small, final light grey, each step smaller than the last, so most of the area stays black.
Start with a light grey over a light primer, then layer lighter greys and off-white, keeping pure white for the highest edges and points.
Usually the paint is too thick or it went on over a dark primer. Use a light primer, a light grey basecoat and thin layers of white.