Paints › Reaper › Tarnished Steel › vs Obsidian BlackTarnished Steel vs Obsidian Black
Brand Reaper Range MSP Metallics Code 09206 Type a metallic Swatch #9e9c9b (estimate)
Brand Vallejo Range True Metallic Metal Code 77.120 Light Type a metallic Swatch #a7a8a8 (estimate) How close are they?
ΔE 4.5, very close: most people won’t see a difference side by side. Obsidian Black is a little lighter than Tarnished Steel.
Can I use Obsidian Black instead of Tarnished Steel? Yes, for most jobs. Very close match (ΔE 4). Obsidian Black is a little lighter than Tarnished Steel.
Can I use Tarnished Steel instead of Obsidian Black? The same difference applies the other way round: Tarnished Steel is a little darker.
ΔE is the colour difference between our two swatch estimates: under about 6 is close, over about 15 is loose. Real paints also differ in finish, coverage and how they thin, so test before you commit.
See Tarnished Steel on the colour wheel See Obsidian Black on the colour wheel
Other Vallejo paints close to Tarnished Steel Other Reaper paints close to Obsidian Black All matches: Tarnished Steel equivalents · Obsidian Black equivalents
© 2026 AK Tabletop Studio. Swatch colours are estimates and will differ from the real paints; cross-brand matches are close, never exact.
Chart-listed matches come from the Two Thin Coats Paint Comparison Chart 2024, the Army Painter Warpaints Fanatic conversion chart, the AK 3rd Generation Acrylics equivalence table (2021) and the Herrick Games hobby paint comparison chart; the rest are a nearest-colour calculation.
The Painters Desk is unofficial and not affiliated with or endorsed by any paint brand. Paint names are trademarks of their owners.
All brands · Guides · Privacy policy · Site rules
Choose a theme Changes how the site looks on this device. Paint colours stay the same.
Paint Pot The original. Follows your light or dark setting. NEON 1984 80s cyberpunk with a synthwave grid. Grimdark Gothic iron, brass and hive spires. Wildwood Misty pines and morning light. DWARVEN Jade peaks, gold rims and forge light. Eldritch Abyss Deep-sea glow, tentacles and runes. Arcane Library Parchment and a celestial chart. FROSTFORGE Ice peaks, aurora and a glowing forge. Infernal Black rock, lava glow and embers. Hobby Bench A painting desk on a cutting mat. Japanese Ink Washi paper, ink-wash mountains and a red sun. Desert Wastes Rust, sand and sun-bleached metal. Sci-fi Lab Clean white, teal and blueprints. Steampunk Workshop Brass pipes, gears and lamplight. Egyptian Tomb Pyramids at dusk, lapis and gold. Void Station Deep space above a blue world.
Done