ΔE 12.7, fair: the same colour family, but not a straight swap. Carmine is a little darker, cooler than Astorath Red. They are different kinds of paint: Citadel Astorath Red is an opaque base/layer paint and Warcolours Carmine is an ink, glaze or transparent paint, so they won’t behave the same on the model even where the colour is close.
Only where an exact match doesn’t matter, such as a new unit or a highlight. Fair match (ΔE 13). Carmine is a little darker, cooler than Astorath Red. They are different kinds of paint.
The same difference applies the other way round: Astorath Red is a little lighter, warmer.
ΔE is the colour difference between our two swatch estimates: under 2 is a perfect match (you’d struggle to tell them apart), under 6 very close, under 10 close, under 15 fair, under 20 loose, under 30 very loose, and 30 or more a poor match. Real paints also differ in finish, coverage and how they thin, so test before you commit.
See Astorath Red on the colour wheel See Carmine on the colour wheel
All matches: Astorath Red equivalents · Carmine equivalents